Fan Question: Not to be a dick, but wasn’t Butters kissed prior to “Butters’ Bottom Bitch”?? I believe he got his first kiss in the episode with the monkey playing the drums and those homeschooled kids!
Answer: You’re not a dick, Scott’s a dick. And you’re actually right on point…even though the boys rip on Butters for never kissing a girl in “Butters’ Bottom Bitch”, he had indeed been kissed by the newly-slutified homeschool girl Rebecca in Season 3’s “Hooked on Monkey Phonics”. However, it’s not a mistake, the explanation is simple — What happens in the Bay of Pigs Memorial Dance stays in the Bay of Pigs Memorial Dance.